top of page
< Back

Fantasy of Manners

Fantasy of manners is a subgenre of fantasy that focuses on social structures, class dynamics, and interpersonal drama, often within settings reminiscent of 18th to 19th-century Europe. These stories combine the nuanced social commentary of the comedy of manners with subtle or limited magical elements, placing an emphasis on dialogue, wit, and the intricate rules of society.

Rather than grand quests or epic wars, fantasy of manners tells tales of courtship, scandal, diplomacy, and intrigue. Magic, if present, is usually understated or constrained by societal norms. The protagonists—often aristocrats, courtiers, or clever commoners—navigate the constraints of class, gender, and etiquette in highly stratified worlds.

This subgenre appeals to readers who enjoy sharp dialogue, character-driven plots, and a focus on the social contract rather than martial prowess. It often blurs the line between fantasy and historical fiction, using fantastical settings to explore real-world social structures and cultural tensions. Fantasy of manners highlights the power of subtlety, manipulation, and intelligence in achieving one’s goals.

What is Fantasy of Manners?

The lord of the rings One ring.jpg

History 

The fantasy of manners evolved from the literary tradition of the comedy of manners, which reached prominence with writers such as Jane Austen and Oscar Wilde. These works employed humour and irony to critique and explore societal norms, particularly among the upper classes. As fantasy literature diversified in the late 20th century, authors began combining these traditions with speculative world-building.


Ellen Kushner’s Swordspoint (1987) is widely regarded as a foundational work in the genre, introducing readers to a fantasy city where politics, relationships, and duels coexist in a culture obsessed with etiquette and honour. Kushner’s world lacks overt magic, relying instead on sophisticated social manoeuvring and character dynamics. This narrative style inspired other writers to explore fantasy settings grounded more in manners than in magical spectacle.


The 1990s and early 2000s saw further development of the subgenre through works like Martha Wells’ The Death of the Necromancer and Susanna Clarke’s Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell, which wove Regency-era sensibilities and magical scholarship into intricate social fabrics. The genre also gained popularity among writers seeking to challenge traditional fantasy tropes by emphasising diplomacy, deception, and conversation over swords and sorcery.


Fantasy of manners has expanded in recent years to incorporate more diverse voices and settings. Authors like Zen Cho (Sorcerer to the Crown) and Tasha Suri (The Jasmine Throne) blend social complexity with unique cultural backgrounds, enriching the genre with fresh perspectives. The rise of queer narratives and nuanced explorations of gender, identity, and power have further energized the subgenre.


Today, fantasy of manners thrives as a refined, character-centric alternative to action-heavy fantasy. It continues to explore how societies function, how people interact within rigid systems, and how change can be wrought through words rather than weapons.

Tropes

  • Social Hierarchies: Power and privilege shape every interaction.

  • Wit and Repartee: Dialogue serves as a battleground for influence.

  • Intrigue and Scandal: Reputation is currency in a world of secrets.

  • Subtle Magic: If present, magic is rare, discreet, or highly regulated.

  • Duels and Decorum: Honor is maintained through ritualized conflict or social ritual.

  • Clever Commoners: Outsiders or underdogs challenge societal norms with intelligence and charm.

  • Manipulative Power Plays: Influence and ambition unfold through schemes and conversation.

Key Reads

  • Swordspoint by Ellen Kushner (1987, Ace Books)
    A landmark novel featuring duels, politics, and class in a decadent city.

  • Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell by Susanna Clarke (2004, Bloomsbury)
    Regency-era England reimagined with scholarly magic and elite intrigue.

  • The Death of the Necromancer by Martha Wells (1998, Eos/HarperCollins)
    Mystery and manners meet necromancy in a Victorian-esque city.

  • Sorcerer to the Crown by Zen Cho (2015, Ace Books)
    A richly diverse take on Regency fantasy, magic, and institutional politics.

Writing Prompts

  1. A debutante discovers her family’s standing hinges on an arranged duel.

  2. A butler manipulates courtly politics to protect his secret identity.

  3. A disinherited noble uses etiquette to outwit magical elites.

  4. A scandal threatens to unravel a carefully negotiated diplomatic alliance.

  5. A magical academy’s headmistress must conceal a forbidden love affair.

  6. A servant with a hidden talent becomes a key player in a noble conspiracy.

  7. A new law banning magic creates quiet rebellion among the upper class.

  8. An aging socialite seeks revenge through carefully orchestrated gossip.

  9. A foreign dignitary plays a dangerous game of etiquette with the royal court.

  10. An enchanted mask forces wearers to speak only the truth—at a gala.

  11. A rivalry between two scholars erupts into a battle of books and secrets.

  12. A marriage proposal hides a deeper political plot—and a magical curse.

bottom of page